Boldmere St Michaels 1 St. Ives Town 1 (BSM win 5-4 on penalties)
F.A. Trophy First Qualifying Round Saturday 29 August 2026
Both teams had a thorough reshuffle from their previous fixture, newly returned James Tague (who returned from his home town’s Basford United, the management who’d signed him having walked out three days before the season’s start) beginning on the bench. In a game as tight as the score would suggest, it needed a splendid diving save, pushing the ball against the post to keep out the visitors’ third penalty, to separate two equally matched teams. The Saints, meanwhile, had only four supporters with them, financial constraints meaning they go everywhere, nowadays, by car.
A paltry crowd foregathered, as driving rain lasted for the first half and, both teams making a brisk start, an end-to-end game resulted. Most corners throughout saw seventeen or so participants in the box, and stout (indeed, bulky) defence made chances few and far between. Nearest to breaking the deadlock came Neo Dobson (shot parried away, after a smart break, on thirty-two minutes) and Jaiy Leydon (getting on the end of good work by Kyle Byrne, his ten-yarder pushed acrobatically away for a corner, three minutes from the break). Half time: 0-0.
A battered Kye Bilton was replaced at the interval. Three minutes into the second period, the Mikes were ahead. Daniel Reka was grounded just outside the penalty area. A four-man wall faced the resultant free kick. Connor Armstrong skilfully guided a curver around it…and the ball tucked itself inside the left-hand post, past the unsighted Jonah Gill. There now ensued the kind of game where you were looking at your watch, asking yourself, “Can Boldmere keep a clean sheet yet again, and pull off another narrow win?” Once the hour had gone, the Saints ramped up the pressure, and eventually it told. Sixty-eight minutes in, a corner was headed on, inside the Mikes’ box, and there was Neo Dobson to rifle it home – an identical goal to the one conceded to Barwell during the week. Within minutes, Dobson nearly doubled his account, firstly with a header, secondly with a shot diverted away for a corner.
Our guests kept up their attacking, and looked the team more likely – though they had to repel a determined home response in the three minutes’ added time. So, to penalties, our ingenious P.A. team playing “Something’s got to give”, as we waited for the spot kicks to begin. St. Ives took first kick, a helpful Adam Harrison insisting on handing each of their penalty takers the ball! Neither keeper stood much chance with well taken penalties, though the Saints’ fourth kick went straight down the middle. By then, however, the tie had been decided. Harrison dived the right way to his opponents’ third effort, pushing it onto his right-hand post, thus keeping it out. On such a small margin is success in knock out competitions sometimes decided.
Boldmere St Michaels: Adam Harrison; Kye Bilton (Pierre Phillips 46); James O’Neill; Daniel O’Callaghan; Pedro Lima; Connor Armstrong; Fraser Doyle; Jaiy Leydon (Maxwell Ngbeken-Itota 69); Omotolani Omotola (James Tague 77); Kyle Byrne (John Atherton 79); Daniele Reka. Sub. not used: Jack Burgess.
St. Ives Town: Jonah Gill; Aidan Edwards; Callum Milne (Ezekiel Williams 79); Mbunya Alemanji (Mark Jones 79); Dan Lawlor; Neo Dobson; Kai Source (Andrian Ankrah 86); Aaron Smith; Ben Kanunda; Lovell Edwards (Jaoa Varela 61); Michael Gash. Sub. not used: Matty Miles.

